James Comey is a Boy Scout and a true believer, and I don’t mean either of those judgements in a pejorative way.


James Comey is a Boy Scout and a true believer, and I don’t mean either of those judgements in a pejorative way. Let me repeat: He’s a Boy Scout in that Scout oath ‘duty-to-God-and-country’ way and a true believer in that Superman ‘truth-justice-and-the-American-way’ way. His explanation of the Martha Stewart case rings authentic in every detail, especially his exasperation at people who make the cardinal error of lying to federal investigators.

…Martha Stewart had told us a whopper, and now we could prove it well beyond any reasonable doubt. Ugh. The lie she had told was so unnecessary. She could have offered to repay the fifty thousand dollars she had saved, chump change to her, expressed remorse, and vowed never to trade on insider infomraion again. Instead she engaged in an elaborate deception and then involved others to try to cover her tracks.

It’s never about the crime, it’s always about the cover-up. You’d think after Nixon and Clinton people would have learned, but no-ooo-oooo.

And Comey’s work as director at the FBI to bring the department into this century can only be described as admirable.

No question, he thinks we’re in trouble

We all bear responsibity for the deeply flawed choices put before voters during the 2016 election, and our country is paying a high price: this president is unethical, and untethered to truth and institutional values. His leadership is transactional, ego driven, and about personal loyalty…What is happening now is not normal. It is not fake news. It is not okay.

but he also believes we’re going to get ourselves out of it, saying that the forest fire that is the Trump administration

…also offers an opportunity to rebalance power among the three branches of our government, closer to the model of the founders intended.

albeit not without some work.

I know there are men and women of good conscience in the Unisted States Congress on both sides of the aisle who understand this. But not enough of them are speaking out…Their silence is complicity—it is a choice—and somewhere deep down they must know that.

Comey is not much of a practical politican; in fact he’s not a politician at all, which is why I believe his account of releasing the news of the resumption of the investigation into Clinton’s emails to the American people two weeks before the 2016 election. If the news broke before the election it might (and did) taint the election, but if it broke afterward and Clinton was elected as everyone at that moment believed she would be, the news would taint her presidency from the getgo. He was damned if he did and damned if he didn’t.

And, really? It wasn’t up to him to make those judgements anyway. It was up to the voters. People in government suck at keeping secrets (yes, I’m including the security services in that judgement, too), and we the people always find out those secrets, usually at the time most inconvenient to the people trying desperately to keep them (vide current events).

His comparisons of the current administration to the mafia dons he prosecuted early in his career are telling

As I found myself thrust into the Trump orbit, I once again was having flashbacks to my earlier career as a prosecutor against the Mob. The silent circle of assent. The boss in complete control. The loyalty oaths. The us-versus-them worldview. The lying about all things, large and small, in service to some code of loyalty that put the organization above moralty and above the truth.

and we should all find them chilling. Recommended.

Read more of my book reviews on Goodreads here.

Book Review Monday Chatter

Dana View All →

Author and founder of Storyknife.org.

8 Comments Leave a comment

  1. A review worthy of the Daily Browse.


    From: Dana Stabenow Reply-To: Dana Stabenow Date: Monday, May 14, 2018 at 10:00 AM To: Kathleen Alcala Subject: [New post] James Comey is a Boy Scout and a true believer, and I don’t mean either of those judgements in a pejorative way.

    Dana posted: ” James Comey is a Boy Scout and a true believer, and I don’t mean either of those judgements in a pejorative way. Let me repeat: He’s a Boy Scout in that Scout oath ‘duty-to-God-and-country’ way and a true believer in that Superman ‘truth-justice-and-the”


  2. I am currently reading your book, “The Singing of The Dead” – my first experience reading your writing. Since we sell many used books where I work, I have heard your fiction recommended in the past. Curiosity compelled me to look you up on the internet… which led me here. Thanks so much for posting this review. I had developed a positive impression of Mr. Comey from other sources. I personally believe that truth is not a malleable thing that can be reshaped at will (although, as they say, the victors write the history books)… what was that phrase again? Oh, yes, some truths remain inalienable! That’s It! Anyway, Thanks Again!


  3. Thanks for your review of the book. I haven’t read it, but have watched many of Comey’s interviews since its publication and I agree with your assessment of his character. I’m not so sure the US will be able to recover from this assault on the democratic system. I have been feeling for a couple of decades that the US is heading into the dark ages, so to speak, where knowledge is not longer respected. I live currently in Afghanistan and often tell my university students that we have Taliban in the US too. Anyway, it was a delight to see this post, since you are a definite favorite among authors (currently rereading Kate Shugak cycle for the 3rd time!)


  4. Great review. I’d already read it and you so eloquently expressed my own thoughts and feelings. Currently reading and thoroughly enjoying “prepared for rage “.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: